When we first broke down HJR 1‑F, the questions came fast: what actually gets cut, what stays on the bill, and who qualifies by when. Here's the fuller, layer-by-layer picture for Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch and Bradenton — no shortcuts.
On June 2, 2026, the Florida Legislature passed the biggest property tax change in the state's history and handed the final call to voters. Our first breakdown covered what HJR 1‑F does. This follow-up covers what it doesn't — the school taxes and flat fees that stay on your bill, the questions readers kept asking about who qualifies, and a couple of points the early headlines understated.
Here on the Gulf Coast, a long-time owner in Sarasota and a recent buyer in Lakewood Ranch can sit a few miles apart and pay wildly different taxes, so the details matter. Below is the honest, layer-by-layer version: what passed, what actually changes on a Suncoast bill, the most common reader questions answered plainly, and an updated estimator that now shows every part of the bill. First, the one thing to keep in mind:
This is not law yet. What passed is a proposed amendment to the Florida Constitution — known as HJR 1‑F, the "Save Our Homes from Excessive Property Taxes" amendment. It cleared the House 75–26 and the Senate 30–9, but a constitutional amendment needs at least 60% of voters to approve it on November 3, 2026.
If voters say yes, the changes phase in starting January 1, 2027. If they don't, today's rules stay in place. Everything below describes what would happen if it passes.
01 — The mechanicsHow a bigger exemption shrinks the bill
Your Florida property tax is built from a simple formula: your taxable value multiplied by the local millage rate (the tax rate per $1,000 of value). A homestead exemption works by lowering the taxable value before the millage is applied. Today, the standard homestead exemption is up to $50,000. The amendment would raise the part that applies to non-school taxes dramatically, in two steps:
The catch — and it's an important one — is hiding in the word non-school. The expanded exemption applies to county, city and most special-district taxes, but not to school district millage. In most Florida counties, school taxes run roughly 6 to 7 mills, so even a fully-exempt home would still owe its school portion. That's why a home worth $250,000 or less wouldn't hit exactly $0 — it would drop to just the school taxes.
One more change for landlords and second-home owners: the amendment would also tighten the annual assessment cap on non-homestead property from 10% down to 5% per year starting in 2027 — slowing how fast taxable value can climb on rentals, vacation homes and commercial property.
02 — The honest partSchool taxes stay — so it's a big cut, not a total wipeout
This is the point the "property taxes eliminated" headlines gloss over, and it's the one readers pushed back on hardest. The expanded exemption never touches school district taxes. Your total bill is built in layers — city millage, county millage, special-district assessments, and school taxes set separately by the school board — and HJR 1‑F only reaches the city and county layers.
So how much of your bill is school taxes? It varies by county, but as a general benchmark, school taxes run roughly 30–40% of a typical Florida homeowner's total property tax bill. The "schools are half your bill" figure that circulated is on the high end — possible in a few counties with steep school millage, but not the statewide norm. Practically, that means HJR 1‑F is a real and significant cut of the non-school portion — potentially all the way to zero on that slice — while the school share holds steady.
HJR 1‑F is a significant non-school property tax cut, not a total elimination. Anyone telling you your bill goes to zero is skipping the school portion; anyone calling it worthless because schools are excluded is ignoring real, compounding savings. The truth sits in the middle — and the estimator below shows exactly where.
Why were schools carved out at all? In short, political survival. An earlier version of the plan was projected to cost school districts on the order of $5 billion a year, drawing heavy opposition from school boards and parent groups. Lawmakers added the school-funding protection to get the measure through — a deliberate trade-off you can judge for yourself, but one that explains why your school taxes keep coming even if the rest of your ad-valorem bill disappears.
03 — The deadlineWhy December 31, 2026 is the date to circle
This is the part the headlines tend to skip. The amendment treats people who are already permanent Florida residents differently from those who arrive later. If you establish your primary Florida residency on or before December 31, 2026, you're in line for the expanded exemption as it phases in.
Move to Florida after that date, and you generally face roughly a five-year wait before you qualify for the full benefit — you'd get a smaller exemption in the meantime and step up to the full amount after maintaining residency for five years. For the snowbirds, relocating professionals and out-of-state buyers, that's the difference between catching this wave and watching it from the beach.
- Already homesteaded here? You're positioned for the benefit if voters approve it — nothing new to do for the residency clock.
- Buying or relocating soon? Closing and establishing permanent residency (and filing for homestead) before year-end 2026 is what keeps you out of the five-year waiting line.
- Snowbird weighing the jump to full-time? Flip to permanent Florida residency and file for homestead before the December 31, 2026 cutoff, and you sidestep the five-year wait altogether.
04 — Who qualifiesThe questions readers keep asking
A lot of the confusion isn't about the big number — it's about whether you qualify, and by when. These are the questions that came up again and again, answered plainly. Tap any to expand.
Q1I've rented in Florida for years. If I buy next year, do I still wait five years for the full exemption?
It feels unfair after years here, but the five-year clock is tied to when you establish homestead on a property, not how long you've rented in Florida. Buy an established homestead after December 31, 2026 and you start at the $50,000 exemption and phase up to the full amount over five years — regardless of how long you've been a resident. The only way to the full benefit from day one is to own and homestead before year-end.
Q2I'll buy before December 31 but miss the March 1 filing deadline. Am I still covered?
December 31 and March 1 are two separate deadlines doing two different jobs. December 31 is the ownership test — you need to own the home and live in it as your primary residence as of January 1 of the tax year. March 1 is the filing deadline to submit your homestead application to the county property appraiser.
Close in late December and you qualify; you simply have until March 1 to file the paperwork. Miss that March 1 and you lose that one year's exemption — but not the overall benefit. File on time and you're fully covered.
Q3Do I have to own my home outright — no mortgage — to qualify?
Homestead applies whether or not you carry a mortgage. What you need is legal title and to be occupying the home as your primary Florida residence as of January 1. Your lender has nothing to do with your homestead eligibility.
Q4I'm a long-time Florida resident who rents and wants to buy. Do I get the full exemption?
It comes down to when you buy an established homestead. Before December 31, 2026: full benefit from day one, same as everyone who beats the deadline. After: the five-year phase-in, same as a brand-new arrival. Your rental history in Florida doesn't change the equation either way — the deadline is the deadline.
Q5Will Florida add a state income tax to replace the lost revenue?
There's a constitutional reason this is harder than it sounds: Florida's constitution currently prohibits a state income tax, and changing that would require its own amendment with the same 60% voter-approval bar. Gov. DeSantis has been explicit that an income tax is off the table. The revenue-replacement levers under discussion are millage adjustments, fees, and spending discipline — not an income tax.
Q6Is this just a Suncoast thing, or all of Florida?
HJR 1‑F is a statewide constitutional amendment. Every Florida homeowner with a homesteaded primary residence benefits if voters approve it in November. We lean on Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch and Bradenton examples because that's our market — but the law applies the same way from Pensacola to Key West.
05 — Fine printThree things the early coverage understated
Fast-moving policy stories tend to flatten the nuance. Three points deserve a clearer look than the first round of headlines gave them — because they change how the bill actually lands.
The renter picture is more nuanced
If cities raise millage on non-homestead property to recoup revenue, landlords can pass that cost along — a legitimate concern. But HJR 1‑F also drops the annual assessment cap on non-homestead property from 10% to 5%, so those assessed values grow more slowly than they do today.
Slower assessment growth means less upward pressure on landlords' tax bills, which eases the pressure to raise rents. The millage risk is real, but it's partly offset by the tighter cap.
The rural-county backfill got scaled back
The Governor's original plan included a state trust fund to cushion small "fiscally constrained" rural counties hit hardest by lost revenue. In the final version, lawmakers removed that trust-fund requirement — a sponsor even stripped references to it from the ballot summary, noting the Legislature never actually funded it.
A long-standing rural-county support program remains, but there's a genuine debate about whether those counties will be fully made whole. Worth knowing before you vote.
Your bill won't be exactly zero
Beyond ad-valorem taxes, most Florida bills carry non-ad-valorem assessments — solid waste, stormwater, and special-district fees charged as flat amounts, not based on your home's value. HJR 1‑F doesn't touch those.
So even if your non-school ad-valorem taxes reach zero in 2028, a line or two of flat fees stays on the bill. For most homeowners those fees are a small slice of the total — but they're why "zero" is never quite zero. The estimator below now includes them.
What actually counts as "non-ad-valorem" on a Suncoast bill
These charges sit on the same annual tax bill as your property taxes, but they aren't based on your home's value — each is set by a unit of measure or benefit, and HJR 1‑F leaves every one of them untouched. On a Sarasota or Manatee County bill, the ones you're most likely to see are:
- Solid waste — garbage, recycling and yard-waste collection. In unincorporated Sarasota County this runs about $264 a year for standard curbside service (FY2026); Manatee County and the individual cities set and bill their own rates.
- Stormwater utility — a flat drainage and water-quality charge levied by the county or your city, regardless of what your home is worth.
- Fire & rescue assessment — worth calling out, because in Sarasota County fire protection is funded by a non-ad-valorem assessment based on square footage, not by millage. That means a meaningful piece of the "fire" cost stays on your bill no matter what the amendment does to ad-valorem taxes.
- Lighting, landscaping & maintenance MSBUs — small district charges for streetlights and neighborhood upkeep in the areas that have them.
- CDD assessments — the big one in master-planned communities like Lakewood Ranch. A Community Development District levies an annual operations-and-maintenance charge plus bond debt service that can add $1,000 to $3,000+ a year, entirely separate from property taxes and completely outside the reach of HJR 1‑F.
Add those lines up and you have your bill's real floor. Even if the 2028 exemption zeroes out your non-school ad-valorem taxes, these assessments remain — modest for many established county homes, but substantial in a CDD community. The non-ad-valorem section of your August TRIM notice lists every one of these charges by name; that total is the figure to drop into the estimator's advanced panel below.
Rule of thumb: the newer and more amenity-rich your community, the larger the non-ad-valorem share of your bill — and the less the exemption alone moves your bottom line.
06 — Run your numbersThe tax-impact estimator
This updated estimator shows every layer of the bill — non-school taxes (the part that gets cut), school taxes (unchanged), and the flat non-ad-valorem fees that stay no matter what. Pick your area, set your home's assessed value, and compare today's rules with the 2027 and 2028 phase-in. Numbers are estimates using approximate local millage — for an exact figure, open the advanced panel and enter the rates and fees straight off your TRIM notice.
Homestead Tax Impact Estimator
How the proposed amendment could change your annual bill
Advanced — edit the millage rates
The expanded exemption applies only to the non-school share (total minus school). Flat fees are non-ad-valorem assessments the amendment doesn't touch — solid waste, stormwater, Sarasota County's fire assessment, and (in communities like Lakewood Ranch) CDD charges that can run $1,000–$3,000+. The $450 default is a base estimate; replace it with the non-ad-valorem total from your TRIM notice. Millage defaults are approximate 2025 rates for each area; your actual TRIM notice is the source of truth.
07 — Closer to homeWhat it looks like across the Suncoast
Because the benefit is tied to assessed value and local millage, this same law lands differently depending on where you are located. A few patterns we'd expect across our service area:
Sarasota
City-of-Sarasota homeowners carry one of the higher combined millage loads in the region, with an extra voter-approved school mill on top. The dollar relief on the non-school portion would be among the largest locally — but the school share keeps a meaningful floor under every bill.
Lakewood Ranch
Spanning east Manatee (and into Sarasota County), many LWR homes sit above the $250,000 assessed mark, so they wouldn't drop to zero — but a $250,000 exemption still carves a large slice off the taxable base. Note: CDD assessments here are separate non-ad-valorem charges this amendment does not touch.
Bradenton
Manatee County's countywide operating rate has hovered around 6 mills, with city and school layered on top. For modestly-valued homesteads in and around Bradenton, the 2028 step to a $250,000 exemption could shrink the non-school bill to nothing, leaving only school taxes.
One thing worth saying plainly: this kind of relief is exactly why your assessed value matters more than ever. When the exemption swallows most of the bill, the few thousand dollars of taxable value that remain — and whether your assessment is fair, accurate and defensible — carries real weight. The same is true if you're appealing an assessment, settling an estate, dividing assets in a divorce, or porting your Save Our Homes benefit to a new home. An independent, USPAP-compliant appraisal is what backs those conversations up.
08 — The calendarDates that decide your outcome
- Jun 2, 2026Legislature passes HJR 1‑FAmendment placed on the November statewide ballot.
- Nov 3, 2026Voters decideNeeds 60% approval to amend the constitution. No vote, no change.
- Dec 31, 2026Ownership / residency deadlineOwn and occupy your primary residence by this date (as of Jan 1) to lock in the full exemption as it phases in — and avoid the multi-year wait.
- Jan 1, 2027Phase one begins$150,000 non-school exemption applies; non-homestead cap drops from 10% to 5%.
- Mar 1, 2027Homestead filing deadlineFile your homestead application with the county property appraiser by this date for the 2027 tax year. Miss it and you forfeit only that year, not the benefit.
- 2028Full exemptionSteps up to $250,000, indexed to inflation beginning 2029.
Make sure the value behind your bill is right.
Whether you're planning a move, contesting an assessment, or just want a clear, independent read on what your Sarasota, Lakewood Ranch or Bradenton home is actually worth, SDI Appraisal delivers evidence-based, USPAP-compliant residential valuations from a local Certified Residential Appraiser with 20+ years of experience.
Request a Free Quote →Stephen D. Ihrig II, SRA
Steve is the principal of SDI Appraisal. He holds the SRA designation from the Appraisal Institute and is a State-Certified Residential Real Estate Appraiser in Florida. Steve practices evidence-based valuation and has provided expert-witness testimony in the Circuit and County Courts of Florida's Twelfth Judicial Circuit for Sarasota and Manatee Counties.
- SRA Designation — The Appraisal Institute, Florida Gulf Coast Chapter
- Member — Forensic Expert Witness Association (FEWA)
- Member — Community of Asset Analysts (CAA)
- Member — REALTOR® Association of Sarasota & Manatee
- Specialties — luxury & waterfront, estate & divorce, date-of-death & step-up basis, price verification, pre-listing, FEMA 50% Rule, IRS casualty loss, litigation & expert witness
Disclaimer: SDI Appraisal provides real estate appraisal and valuation services. We are not tax advisors, attorneys or financial advisors, and this article is for general information only — not tax, legal or financial advice. HJR 1‑F is a proposed constitutional amendment that has not been enacted; its provisions take effect only if approved by Florida voters and may change. Calculator results are estimates based on simplified assumptions and approximate millage rates and will not match your official tax bill. Verify all details with the Sarasota County or Manatee County Property Appraiser and consult a qualified professional before making decisions.
Sources: Florida House & Senate analyses of HJR 1‑F / SB 4F (flhouse.gov, flsenate.gov); reporting on the June 2, 2026 passage, the $250,000 homestead exemption, the public-school funding carveout, the non-homestead assessment-cap change, and the removal of the rural-county backfill trust fund; Sarasota County Solid Waste District FY2026 rates (scgov.net) and Sarasota County / Manatee County Property Appraiser and Tax Collector non-ad-valorem assessment guidance; Manatee County and Sarasota County millage data (2025). School-tax share, fire-assessment, CDD, and flat-fee figures are general estimates that vary by parcel; verify against your own TRIM notice and tax bill.
SDI Appraisal Mission Statement
Committed to empowering our clients with clarity and direction.
Stephen D. Ihrig II, SRA is principal of SDI Appraisal, specializing in the valuation of residential real estate. Steve has been providing appraisal and consulting services since 2003. Currently a Certified Residential Appraiser in the State of Florida, Steve was awarded the SRA designation from the Appraisal Institute.
In today’s ever-changing real estate market, utilize only the best and most qualified individuals to perform your residential appraisals. An accurate value supported by data and analysis, that reflects market trends, can hold up in any court of law, is considered a high-quality report by any lender’s underwriting system, and meets all USPAP (Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice) standards should be your primary objective when retaining a real estate appraiser.
Specialized Professional Education and Development
- SRA Designation, Appraisal Institute
- Private Appraisal Assignments: Attorneys, Accountants, Property Owners, Trusts & other entities
- Expert Witness Testimony
- Real Estate Finance Statistics and Valuation Modeling
- Relocation Appraisal
- REO Appraisal: Appraisal of Residential Property Foreclosure
- FHA & USDA Approved Appraiser
- Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP)
- Michigan State University Alumni